What factors influence a decision to accept/refuse a potential Ph.D. student as a professor? - PhDData

Access database of worldwide thesis

What factors influence a decision to accept/refuse a potential Ph.D. student as a professor?

September 2022

Professors may have varying admissions requirements based on their field of study, academic standing, and years of teaching experience. Candidates are evaluated based on the information provided in their applications, including their academic results, motivation and persistence, evidence of their intellectual curiosity, their personality type, breadth of life experiences, and recommendations of those closest to them. Students don’t necessarily need to excel in every academic area. Still, they should be able to think critically, collaborate well with others, and have a positive attitude and work ethic no matter their challenges. One bad apple could ruin the entire laboratory, so; the professors are conscientious while selecting potential candidates. Here we will look at the most critical factors that the professors consider to accept or refuse a Ph.D. student.


An essential factor a professor considers is the solid academic background of a student. Your academic performance, diverse experience in research, intellectual curiosity, and level of perseverance are all considered by the professor deeply. Whether the students have a solid technical foundation, including the ability to program, knowledge of probability, and evidence of research, all are counted in the background.


The motivation level is determined through an interview. The supervisor will evaluate the level of inquisition, the level of drive a student has to add something new to the old, and how much he is attentive to their goals. He also noted how much he is curious to explore and how much he is willing to learn and respectful. The higher the level of motivation is, the higher chances are of being accepted by the professor.


Funding is also one of the critical factors. How much funding is available? A professor has to ensure students have RAs through their entire program, so they only hire students if they think they will be able to fund them through the entirety of the program. It’s also important that the student selected for finance deserves it.   For this reason, the professor considers only those doing great in their perspective field.


How long does it take for a professor to go through an application? If he decides to enroll students, he would undoubtedly want to speak with them beforehand to gauge their interest and spend some time with them after admission to recruit them. If he can’t do either, he’s less likely to admit students because he’ll want to do an excellent job of recruiting.

Research Proposal

A research Proposal is the most viable factor in determining the selection of the prospective student. How compelling is your research proposal and what kind of impact will it generate, how much attention-grabbing is it, and how detailed and precise? The professor will take into account all these factors to finalize your selection.

Number of enrolled students

The difference between the number of students the professor has now (and where they are in the program) and the number of students he would like to have. is also one of the critical factors. He will likely employ additional students if he decides he needs them. He probably won’t take on any other interns if he already has too many. In short, these factors influence the professor’s decision to accept/refuse a potential Ph.D. student. As consequence, students should be aware of them while applying for their doctoral studies at a specific institute and professor.

Read the last PhD tips